This site is a developmental version of Wiki Law School. To go to the production site: www.wikilawschool.org
Beachcomber Coins v. Boskett: Difference between revisions
m (DeRien moved page Beachcomber Coins, Inc. v. Boskett to Beachcomber Coins v. Boskett: shorten) |
mNo edit summary |
||
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
One of these aforesaid Mercury dimes was the basis of a contract between Beachcomber Coins, Inc. ("Beachcomber") & Boskett. | One of these aforesaid Mercury dimes was the basis of a contract between Beachcomber Coins, Inc. ("Beachcomber") & Boskett. | ||
Beach-comber was a retailer in coins. Mr. Boskett was a part-time coin dealer. Boskett | Beach-comber was a retailer in coins. Mr. Boskett was a part-time coin dealer. Boskett claimed to possess a Denver 1916 Mercury dime for $450. | ||
After a 45-minute inspection of the said coin, Beach-comber agreed to pay $500 for it to Boskett. | After a 45-minute inspection of the said coin, Beach-comber agreed to pay $500 ([https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=US%24500+%281979+US+dollars%29 $2,100 in 2023]) for it to Boskett. | ||
Alas, the experts at the American Numismatic Society determined the coin Beach-comber had bought to be a counterfeit. | Alas, the experts at the American Numismatic Society determined the coin Beach-comber had bought to be a counterfeit. |
Latest revision as of 10:29, August 2, 2023
Beachcomber Coins v. Boskett | |
Court | Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division |
---|---|
Citation | 400 A.2d 78 |
Date decided | March 2, 1979 |
Facts
In 1916, the Denver Mint produced a small # of dimes featuring the visage of Mercury, the Roman god of commerce & trickery. Because of their rarity, their value has skyrocketed; at the same time, these coins have become an attractive item for counterfeiters!
One of these aforesaid Mercury dimes was the basis of a contract between Beachcomber Coins, Inc. ("Beachcomber") & Boskett.
Beach-comber was a retailer in coins. Mr. Boskett was a part-time coin dealer. Boskett claimed to possess a Denver 1916 Mercury dime for $450.
After a 45-minute inspection of the said coin, Beach-comber agreed to pay $500 ($2,100 in 2023) for it to Boskett.
Alas, the experts at the American Numismatic Society determined the coin Beach-comber had bought to be a counterfeit.Procedural History
Beach-comber sued Boskett to seek rescission of the purchase due to a mutual mistake regarding the genuineness of the coin.
The judge held in favor of Boskett; the judge stated that a professional coin purchaser assumed the risk of buying a fake coin.